As this project began to take shape and I started casting about for the
wireless tools of choice, it didn't take long to notice that two terms
kept coming up over and over: the Linksys WET11 wireless ethernet
bridge, and the Senao 2511CD PLUS EXT2 wireless PCMCIA card. As
of this writing (mid-2005), both have something of a cult following
among wireless geeks; the WET11 is small and allows any
ethernet-enabled device to inexpensively acquire a Wi-Fi connection,
and the Senao card has a hot receiver and can transmit up to 249mW...
way more than the stock cards that are typically used in laptops.
It's also superior to the one in the WET11, which is what led to this retrofit.
First, it's important to note that there are two flavors of the
Linksys WET11, and if you're going to do this retrofit, you must have
the older version... and they are getting a bit scarce (I found mine on
eBay). This model shipped with a PCMCIA Bromax card, which can
simply be unplugged and replaced... and they also can be adapted simply
to support power-over-Ethernet (see the excellent how-to here). The newer WET11 does not
have a replaceable Wi-Fi card and I am not aware of any modifications
that can bring it to the maximum legal power level.
To help prevent any more warranty-voiding than necessary, note that the
newer one without the card is co-branded with Cisco, so it's easy to
identify without prying off the rubber feet and breaking the
label.
Here are the internals of the two WET11 versions:
The NEW version of the Linksys WET11, not hackable
The original version of the WET11, with replaceable Wi-Fi card
Assuming you have the original WET11 and a Senao card, the swap is
pretty trivial... but there is one little mechanical nuisance that
should be dealt with. See the little end cap on the PCMCIA card in the photo above,
with the screws going down into stand-offs? Well, the Senao
doesn't have that. For a physically static application, that
won't much matter, and a cable tie around the whole thing can (crudely)
hold it in place, but in some applications (like Shacktopus), a bit more retention is necessary to prevent vibration or shock from shaking the card loose from the connector pins.
In my case, I decided to provide a little step below the flat plastic
end of the Senao card; this allows a retention clip for maximum
serviceability, or an adhesive such as 3M double-sided tape for
bomb-proof reliability. I shortened the original brass stand-offs
to .330" tall, and added a thin aluminum shelf with countersunk holes
for the metric screws:
New aluminum nest for Senao card on original WET11 standoffs
As you can see in the photo, I kept the pigtail
from the MMCX card connector to the RP-SMA antenna connector on the
board edge; I'll use the original WET11 rubber duck on the secondary
Senao antenna position to provide diversity receive performance.
The
primary antenna (the one closer to the top in the photo below, marked
with a star) is carried to a pivoting 5.5 dBi rubber duck on
the case exterior, which can be unscrewed to allow connection of a
beautiful
7-element, 12 dB yagi that is small enough (16" long) to fit in the Shacktopus carrying case. Both of those antennas are from RadioLabs.
Here's what it looks like, all assembled in the polycarbonate enclosure:
Senao 2511CD PLUS EXT2 card mounted on original version of Linksys WET11
This installation is still serviceable, as I have not yet added double-sticky
tape or other adhesive between the Senao card and the aluminum
nest. The gray clip in the photo was hacked from an old Panduit
cable-retainer, and snaps nicely into place. As my use of
the system stabilizes, I'll add goo if necessary to make it more solid.
Incidentally, I'd suggest a couple of additional minor hacks if you are
building one of these into a portable system. First, the toroidal coil
with the blob of hot-glue was not actually stabilized to the board in
my case, and I saw another photo on the net that looked about the
same. This may be an assembly error, or it may be intended solely
to prevent microphonics, but in any case that's a very massy object
dangling off two spindly pieces of solid wire. I added a
couple of dabs of hot glue to keep it from flopping around and failing.
Second, there are only two mounting holes in the WET11 PC board, largely
because in the original packaging that is quite sufficient. At
the moment I am only using those with a couple of thick fiber washers,
and depend on a slight preload against the bottom stand-off screws to
provide stability. It would be a bit better to use the
stand-off close to the front edge (just visible under the nearest MMCX
connector in the photo above) to receive a third mounting screw.
A future article in this series will deal with the more
networking-related issues in this installation... so far I have only
performed basic tests in the lab, a 3,000 square foot metal
building full of Wi-Fi (hardly a challenging environment for all this
high-performance gear!)
The Senao 2611-CB3
It has been pointed out since this article was posted (thanks, Dan!)
that there is now a product available from Senao that eliminates the
need to retrofit an obsolete model of the Linksys WET11. This
unit incorporates the 2511 card and provides similar
functionality: the 2611-CB3.
The board has four mounting holes, is 3.75 x 4.75 x 0.75 inches, and is
already configured for POE without an extractor necessary. The 200 mW
card is the same as shown in the photos above; here's a look at the
innards of a slightly earlier version (almost identical):
Senao 2611-CB3
So it looks like Shacktopus II will use one of these, instead of requiring me to prowl eBay for a discontinued model to retrofit!